Accommodations At Compass Cay

Accommodations on Compass Cay are inviting and in tune with the natural surroundings. All individual villas are nestled amongst native vegetation affording the utmost in privacy and beauty. All homes offer spectacular views of the marina, Pipe Cay, and the Exuma Sound. Accommodations are equipped with all that is needed for an enjoyable stay. Full kitchen, bath, and linen included.

Living area with view of surrounding islands and Pipe Creek area

Master Bedroom
w/bath

One of two bedrooms in Lilly’s Villa

Living Room leading out to patio

Lilly’s Villa

Lilly’s Villa is comprised of two bedrooms and two baths. All rooms are air-conditioned and also have ceiling fans. All linens are supplied. All floors are tiled, and the kitchen is fully equipped with everything except your food and beverages. Your own propane barbeque is located outside, on the porch.

Two-Bedroom Lilly’s Villa
2 guests $3,200
3 guest $3,400
4 guests $3,800 Max Guest Allowed

(pricing does not include taxes)
We are now offering long-term rentals for our villas! Monthly and even yearly rentals are now available; please contact us for more info.

The Lodge

The Lodge is set in its own island vegetation on a high ridge with 360-degree water views. Private paths lead from the large veranda on the ocean side of The Lodge to Crescent Beach. From the sixty-foot porch on the West side of the Lodge, you will delight in the constantly changing colors of the waters of the Pipe Creek area and the blazing oranges of the evening sunset. Your private stone path winds down through the woods to the marina and harbor area.

Airy and spacious, the Lodge has a 30′ x 25′ open central living and dining area, featuring spectacular views from the numerous screened doors and windows. The three-bedroom, one-bath Lodge sleeps six, with double beds in two bedrooms and a Queen bed in the third. The bedrooms are air-conditioned and also have ceiling fans. All linens are supplied. All floors are tiled, and the kitchen is fully equipped with everything except your food and beverages. Your own propane barbecue is located outside, on the porch. Weekly rental guests have access to a Boston Whaler when available to use to explore the surrounding islands!

Weekly rates for The Lodge:

2 guests $3,400
3 guests $3,600
4 guests $3,800
5 guests $4,000
6 guests $4,200 Max Capacity NO Exceptions

We are now offering long-term rentals, monthly and even yearly! Please contact us for more information

(pricing does not include tax levy)

Master bedroom ocean side leading out onto deck overlooking ocean

Bedroom # 3 over
looking marina

Well appointed kitchen with wet bar to the right

Crescent Beach House up on left feet away from worlds finest beach

Crescent Beach House overlooking Exuma Sound

Living Room leading
out to patio

Master Bedroom w/bath

Guest room w/separate bath

Crescent Beach House

The Crescent Beach House, located on the Exuma Sound side of the island, just steps away from one of the most beautiful private beaches in the world. This two-bedroom, two-bath villa is the perfect beach comer. Exit the spacious living room, kitchen area by double French doors onto the front porch, where the romantic view is described by a National Geographic photographer as the “Prettiest water I have ever seen, and I have seen plenty around the world. Nothing compares to the waters of the Bahamas around Compass Cay”.

Looking out to sea, you will discover “Refrigerator Rock,” getting its name from the islanders who used to dive every day for fresh fish and lobster. Having no refrigeration years ago, there was no better way to get your meal fresh from the sea. With your weekly rental, you have access to a Boston Whaler when available to use to explore the surrounding islands!

Weekly rates for Crescent Beach House:
2 guests $3,200
3 guests $3,400
4 guests $3,800 Max Capacity NO Exceptions

We are now offering long-term rentals for our villas! Monthly and even yearly rentals are now available; please contact us for more info.

MANGO HOUSE (NOT AVAILABLE FOR 2022 OR 2023)

The Mango House set 45 feet above sea level overlooking Bonefish Creek. A breeding ground for many fish, this Villa is Just steps away from some of the best bone-fishing in the Exumas.

This two-bedroom, one-bath villa is the perfect spot for fishing enthusiasts. The kitchen and living area are the perfect spots to save the day's catch, and after, take a leisurely kick ride up the creek to visit nature. Just a reminder, there is no fishing in the marina, only up the creek or outside the harbor. With your weekly rental, you have access to a Boston Whaler, when available, to use to explore the surrounding islands!

Weekly rates for the Mango House:

2 guests $2,400
3 guests $2,800
4 guests $ 3,200 Max Capacity